9 Ways to Have a Top 1% Gift Card Program Management Plan

In today's retail and hospitality sectors, gift card programs are more important than ever. According to our 2023 Restaurant Gift Card Sales Report, gift card sales surpassed $326 million in 2022. More people are buying gift cards online, with record numbers in total cards sold and digital sales. 

For businesses, gift cards are a way to increase revenue and improve customer engagement. Data indicates that well-executed gift card strategies can deepen customer loyalty and maximize return on investment (ROI).

You might be thinking, "Where do I begin?" This article will acquaint you with the basics. Let’s go!

5 Key Factors for Gift Card Program Success 

Launching an effective gift card program involves more than making cards available to customers. It requires careful planning and execution of the following five key factors: 

1. Use Clear, Branded Designs

Your gift card designs give customers a first impression of your program. The cards must be visually appealing and aligned with your brand identity, reflecting your brand's essence in a way that encourages purchase and gifting. 

Whether digital or physical, the gift card design should resonate with your target audience.  

2. Establish a Robust Tracking System

An effective tracking system is vital for gift card program management. Such a system ensures accurate financial management and provides insights into your program's impact on sales.  

The tracking system captures when customers buy and redeem gift cards, providing essential data for identifying sales trends and preferences. It also gathers insights into the days of the week, times of day, and methods of redemption.  

This valuable information can be used to refine your services and products. Implementing a robust gift card software solution that offers real-time analytics further enhances your program's efficiency, profitability, and cash flow management, allowing you to adapt dynamically to customer behaviors. 

3. Seamless Integration with Existing Payment Systems

For a gift card program to be functional, it must integrate with your existing restaurant payment system. This integration simplifies transactions for customers and staff, ensuring a smooth redemption process at every point of sale, in-store or online. Such fluid integration ensures the redemption process is smooth and error-free, significantly improving the customer experience.  

Additionally, by minimizing technical disruptions and operational problems, this integration allows staff to focus on customer service rather than payment processing issues. This speeds up transaction times and strengthens security measures, ensuring that every transaction is secure and compliant with payment industry standards.

4. Comprehensive Legal Compliance

Adhering to legal standards is crucial in designing and implementing a gift card program. To avoid legal problems, clearly communicate any additional fees associated with your gift card program. Always respect consumer rights regulations to maintain trust with your customers. 

For example, under the Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure (CARD) Act, gift cards sold by restaurants must not have expiration dates less than five years from the date of purchase. Additionally, inactivity fees can only be charged if the card has not been used for at least one year. For more details, refer to the guidelines provided by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. 

5. Customer Support and Service

Providing excellent customer support is crucial for resolving any issues arising from purchasing or using gift cards. A support system helps customers with questions about card balances, store credit, expiration, and redemption options, enhancing user experience and encouraging customers to return.  

For example, implementing a comprehensive support system with a support articles hub, customer service chat, email, and an FAQ section can improve customer experience. These tools ensure that customers have multiple channels to seek assistance and resolve their issues promptly.

4 Best Practices in Gift Card Management 

Gift card program management requires a strategic approach encompassing best practices to maximize efficiency, ensure security, and improve customer satisfaction.  

Businesses sell gift cards to increase revenue and accelerate loyalty, which is easier when gift card and loyalty program designs are similar. Therefore, understanding how to manage gift card programs effectively is essential for both short- and long-term profitability. 

The following are four essential practices to safeguard the program's integrity and optimize its impact. Using these practices, you can make gift cards valuable to your business's overall engagement strategy. 

1. Managing Your Digital Gift Card Inventory: As e-gift cards become popular, managing your inventory digitally is imperative. It involves ensuring that digital gift cards are secure, easily accessible, and integrated within broader marketing strategies. Focusing on gift cards available through mobile devices can improve the user experience for busy modern consumers. 
2. Ensuring Legal Compliance: Gift card programs must adhere to federal and state regulations, including expiration dates and fee restrictions. Understanding and complying with these laws protect your business and build customer trust. Being clear about the rules for your gift cards can prevent unhappy customers and legal problems. 
3. Developing Targeted Marketing Strategies: To get more people using your gift cards, create marketing plans that target the customers you want to reach. Promotions like bonus cards, discounts on bulk purchases, or seasonal campaigns will drive sales. One way to increase sales is to link gift card promotions to holidays or events. This also plays on the fact that consumers spend more during these periods. However, many customers prefer physical gift cards in-store during holidays, because they’re a favorite of those who like physical gifts. 
4. Implementing Fraud Prevention Measures: With digital transactions always increasing, fraud prevention is more important than ever. Encrypted transactions, secure APIs, and regular audits will help protect your business and customers from misuse. Monitoring and updating your protocols is critical to staying ahead of fraud. 

Digital Gift Card Programs: Optimizing Integration and Management 

Gift card programs must adapt to the needs of tech-savvy consumers in the fast-changing digital world. These consumers prioritize convenience and speed, so they must evolve accordingly to remain relevant. 

Integrating digital gift cards with existing technology systems helps you and your team manage them effectively. Strong management practices are also essential for successfully managing e-gift card programs. These practices should address the specific challenges of digital cards compared to physical ones. 

Managing Digital vs. Physical Card Programs 

Digital cards are easy to use and affordable. However, millions of people still prefer physical gift cards because they can physically hold and hand them to recipients. Managing both options requires a balanced approach that satisfies each's unique advantages. 

By understanding your customers' preferences, your business can make informed decisions about your inventory and promotional strategies. This approach can ultimately increase sales and customer satisfaction. 

The Bottom Line: Ensuring Effective Program Management 

Managing gift card programs efficiently involves creating, improving, and adapting them to meet evolving consumer needs and technology changes. Tools and resources that streamline these processes substantially elevate the effectiveness and flexibility of your gift card offerings. 

Small businesses can use gift card programs to improve cash flow and attract more customers. Moreover, continuous monitoring and adaptation based on customer feedback ensures your program remains dynamic and aligned with local, national, and global trends. 

To better understand and use effective gift card strategies, check out our Marketer's Guide to Gift Card Strategy. This guide gives helpful advice on adjusting to changes in gift card buying habits and ways to increase your business's sales. Dive into this resource to ensure your gift card program is as successful and profitable as possible.